Ubiquity should never be mistaken for greatness. Case in point? In a city like Toronto, pizza is everywhere. Finding the best pizza Toronto has to offer? That’s another matter entirely. A city that shows no particular allegiance to a specific style, its culinary scene is an equal-opportunity tapestry of thin- and thick-crust gems, with pizzas dotted with staunchly traditional toppings and others tiled with outré garnishes shaped by time and place. Locals may never agree on the supremacy of one type, one pie, or one specific slice, but anyone searching for the best pizza in Toronto would be remiss to neglect these top spots.
Bar Sugo
The checkered tablecloths may be green and white, rather than the usual red, and the star dish is brick-oven pizza, not sauce-napped noodles, but this sibling to Sugo sticks to the Italian-American theme that made its sister a resounding success. Pizzas here, 14-inch rounds marked by proximity to flame, are yeasty and supple, the toppings a homage to the owners’ Toronto upbringings. With an unpretentious menu served in a room that chitters with Gen Z energy, this neighbourhood spot has the lived-in feel of the classic pizzerias it aims to honour.
Beast Pizza
Those looking to upgrade their pizza-eating beyond pep cups and pepper rings will swoon at the gourmet toppings found at this unapologetic neighbourhood hangout. A second incarnation of Beast, chef Scott Vivian’s bold nose-to-tail eatery, Beast Pizza slings New York-style pizzas constructed on poolish dough that’s gloriously elastic yet sturdy enough to support chef Nate Middleton’s penchant for creativity. Cheese and pepperoni satisfy the timid, while Beef Patty, Wiener Wheel and Aloo Gobi—a fragrant creation anointed with coconut milk and potato curry, then finished with brinjal pickle—showcase what the team can really do, resulting in some of the best pizza in Toronto.
Danny's Pizza Tavern
Making the type of wood-fired pizza Toronto covets, this lived-in, laidback Little Italy hangout is easy to love. Still, it’s the quality of the tavern pies landing on every table that put it above other cheap-and-cheerful destinations. Each an ode to cracker-crisp Midwestern pizzas, they’re edible Americana, topped edge-to-edge the way any respectable Midwesterner would demand—aka, generously. Though classics are well-represented in margherita, Hawaiian and pepperoni pies, the team also garnishes its signature dough with chimichurri and fior di latte or tandoori chicken and mint chutney, proving that the best tributes are generally backed by personal style.
Descendant Detroit-Style Pizza
A full-on sensory experience, eating at this East-End restaurant escalates from heady aromas to the feeling of grasping a slice, hearing its frico-crusted edge shatter between your teeth and, finally, tasting extravagance in pizza form. Descended (get it?) from Sicilian sfincione, pies here are focaccia-like and fluffy, a slow bake in a deck oven lending each one its signature crackly, craggy crust. Boasting a menu of garnishes designed to reflect the city’s renowned multiculturalism—from kothu roti and jerk chicken to Barese sausage, and more—this spot proves that Detroit pizza in Toronto is a category all its own.