Sorry, you need to enable JavaScript to visit this website.

The best pizza in Toronto

From Napoletana pies to Detroit-style squares and New York slices: our pick of the best pizza in Toronto
Pepperoni pizza at Danny's Pizza Tavern.

Danny's Pizza Tavern

One Night Only Pizza

Though its pizza is now technically available four nights a week, One Night Only is best approached with some forethought, lest you be unprepared when slots for pre-order pizza pick-up are released each Monday. Play the game, and your reward will be lunch or dinner that’s breathtaking in both appearance and flavour, thanks to thoughtful toppings, burnished cheese zones, and an organic crust fermented for 72 hours, for optimal flavour, foldability and chew. Inspired by his own predilections, chef-owner Luke Pollard never shies away from creative toppings, whether that’s garlic cream with bacon and baked potato or house gochujang sauce with smoked mozzarella and pepperoni.

Pizzeria Badiali

The quintessential neighbourhood slice shop, Badiali brought yeasty, bubbled crusts, precise toppings, and impossibly long lines to the city’s west end in 2021. A pandemic-era pivot for chef Ryan Baddeley, the takeout spot is as much a faithful recreation of a nostalgic ideal as it is a place for Baddeley, from a fine-dining background, to showcase his commitment to quality. Yes, you’ve had pepperoni and vodka pies before, but built on Baddeley’s implausibly crisp, chewy dough, they and their New York-style menu-mates reach supernal status. For seating, and a taste of the team’s hefty, old-school grandma pies, the restaurant’s Mirvish Village location is also unmissable. [Various locations]

Pizzeria Libretto 

When chef Rocco Agostino and restaurateur Max Rimaldi opened Pizzeria Libretto in 2008, their mission was simple: to make the type of Neapolitan pizza Toronto had never seen, seducing diners with pies made to the strict criteria set out by Naples’ pizza-governing body. The gamble paid off, and the restaurant awakened the city’s appetite for hand-stretched, 00-flour pies, traditionally garnished and baked at scorching temperatures until soft in the centre, puffed around the edges and properly dappled with leopard-style spots. Showcasing pizza’s vast potential, it pushed Toronto diners to demand more than flabby cardboard pies and sparked a golden age of pizza-making that’s still going strong today. [Various locations]

Slowhand Sourdough Pizza

Like so many, Brett Feeley and Daniel Ewing used pandemic lulls to their advantage: perfecting their slow-fermented sourdough recipe and selling out pop-ups with their pillowy, deep-dish pies. Buoyed by their viral fame, the duo moved into permanent Leslieville digs in 2022. There, and at their newest location in King West, they crank out more pies, with more toppings, to more adoring fans. Taking cues from Rome, Sicily, Detroit and San Francisco, the team’s hand-crafted dough is achingly airy, its bronzed edges trimmed with delicately lacy frico projections. Inside, a topography of tiny indents and gaping chambers serves as undeniable evidence of the expertly tamed living culture behind every bite. [Various locations]

Spread the flavour—share this story

Join the community
Badge
Join us for unlimited access to the very best of Fine Dining Lovers
Unlock all our articles
Badge
Register now to continue reading and access all our exclusive stories.

Already a member? LOG IN